Last year a lower-court judge ruled that Nigerian families who claim that Pfizer used their children as guinea pigs to test new drugs had to file their suits in Nigeria. But the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit in New York ruled on Friday that they can sue the pharmaceutical giant in U.S. courts after all.
This is a home run for us. The judges are making a statement. They are telling companies, ‘If you go overseas, justice will come back to the United States.’
(Richard P. Altschuler, an attorney for the families)
Indeed, I am truly hopeful that this will lead not only to Pfizer having to pay billions in compensation to these families but also to its executives being incarcerated in Nigeria, where, after international pressure, Nigerian authorities are now prosecuting them on criminal charges as well.
For now though, I shall suffice to reprise my July 23, 2007 commentary on this case:
[I]t was brilliantly acted and dramatized the all-too-real exploits of corrupt governments and multi-national (pharmaceutical) corporations that routinely entail sacrificing human lives for profit – especially African lives that are regarded so cheaply, universally.
Therefore, I was truly heartened when the BBC reported last week that the Nigerian government has filed a lawsuit against pharmaceutical hegemon Pfizer. In this landmark class-action case, Nigeria alleges that Pfizer scientists conducted illegal trials of an anti-meningitis drug (Trovan) that they knew or should have known would kill or deform hundreds of Nigerian children – as it surely did.
Even worse, the suit alleges that these scientists duped Nigerian parents into offering up their children as guinea pigs. This horrific allegation stems from the fact that, after a severe outbreak of meningitis in 1996, radio broadcasts urged concerned parents to take their children “as quickly as possible,” to local clinics, where international aid workers from Medecins Sans Frontieres (Doctors Without Borders) were administering free emergency treatment.
Critically, however, the parents were not told that agents from Pfizer had also set up shop at those clinics and were slipping their children an “unregistered and unapproved trial drug as part of this treatment.”
The American doctors took advantage of our illiteracy and cheated us and our children. We thought they were helping us.
We did not suspect that our children were being used for an experiment. They have cheated us and our children. All I can say is that God will judge them according to their evil deeds.
[Hassan Sani – whose daughter Hajara (pictured here) was one of the lucky victims]
It is regrettable, however, that this is only a civil action to collect money for pain and suffering; especially since it would take only chump change for Viagra-producing Pfizer to pay-off the $7bn in damages being sought.
After all, if the Nigerian government really wanted to vindicate and honor the lives of these innocent victims, it would follow the lead of its Kano regional government by pursuing criminal prosecutions to imprison Pfizer’s Mengeles for serial manslaughter and murder….
Meanwhile, I appreciate that the film probably dramatizes this dark secret of American enterprise in too entertaining a fashion to incite the level of outrage that would compel a multi-national corporation like Pfizer to stop its exploitation of the poor Africans for profit. And I fear that even this court trial will do little more in this respect.
Therefore, I highly recommend you buy the book by John LeCarre on which the film is based. Because reading it is far more likely to evoke the kind of moral indignation against this constant gardening in Africa that is warranted.
Perhaps you recall that back in 1972 the New York Times exposed the U.S. government for conducting “the longest non-therapeutic experiment on human beings [namely, poor black sharecroppers in Alabama] in medical history.” In fact, the experiment ran from 1932 until this exposé incited such universal condemnation that the government was compelled to end its “Tuskegee Syphilis Study” post haste and pay $10 million to compensate the victims and their heirs – to forestall a class action lawsuit.
Yet those who condemned the government for this syphilis experiment appear to have no conscientious objection to the fact that U.S. pharmaceutical corporations are experimenting with new drugs on Africans to ensure their safety for Americans. And this unconscionable practice is hardly redeemed by Pfizer’s self-righteous claim that its experiments are for the good of all mankind, not merely for the benefit of its shareholders; nor by its even more specious claim that it secured consent decrees from all of these guinea pigs beforehand….
So, where’s the outrage!!!
NOTE: The next time you hear that primitive customs make Africans suspicious of lifesaving vaccinations that westerners take for granted (like those for polio), think of the barbaric practices of pharmaceutical companies that have given them just cause to be suspicious….
Related Articles:
2006 Academy Awards
Pfizer’s Mengeles
Legacy Note: With over 5,600 posts spanning 20 years, I am easily the most prolific blogger on the most eclectic array of topics on the web. That makes The iPINIONS Journal an unparalleled archive of informed political and cultural commentary. Visit the ARCHIVES section in the sidebar or search by topic. You won’t find a more consistent, independent voice on world affairs.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.